RESULTS

Affray and Assault – Withdrawn

Case: Early Morning Trespass and Threats Leads to Affray Charges.

Our client and his house mate were charged with affray and assault after two drunken and unidentified men attended their front door at 2:00am in the morning. 

Charges/ Ch1 (Affray); Ch2, Ch3 (Unlawful Assault)

Result/ All charges withdrawn

The complainants made statements the next day after their wives told them to go to the police. Our lawyer pointed out inconsistencies in the statements given that the complainants admitted they were heavily intoxicated, as well as the fact that there were no members of the public present to justify the affray charge. In his interview, our client was clear, consistent and concise in his account of what happened in that one of the men threatened his house mate and threw the first punch. This was sufficient to raise self defence and unlawful trespass by the complainants as a defence.

Intentionally Cause Injury and Assault – Withdrawn

Case: Charged with Assault & Cause Injury With Identity In Issue.

Our client was charged with intentionally cause injury in circumstances where the complainant did not identify our client and evidence suggested another offender.

Charges/ Ch1 (Intentionally Cause Injury); Ch2 (Unlawful Assault)

Result/ All charges withdrawn

The complainant in this case had an extensive criminal history and described an incident that caused his injuries that was inconsistent with the incident our client was accused of. Further, there was no witness that identified our client. Our lawyer adjourned the matter to a Contested Hearing where prior to the Hearing police withdrew the charges.

Recklessly/Negligently Cause Serious Injury Withdrawn – Resolved on Dangerous Driving

Case: Office of Public Prosecutions Wastes Resources Prosecuting Father For Riding Accident.

Our client was riding with his child on a minibike a short distance to his house to go to the toilet. He was distracted momentarily talking to his child and collided with a parked trailer. The child was injured in the incident. 

Charges/ Ch1 (Recklessly Cause Serious Injury); Ch2 (Negligently Cause Serious Injury); Ch3 (Reckless Conduct Endangering Serious Injury); Ch4 (Drink Driving); Ch5 (Dangerous Driving); Ch6 (Careless Driving); Ch7 (Intentionally Cause Injury)

Result/ Ch 1 to 4, 6, 7 withdrawn; Ch5 Plead Guilty (Dangerous Driving): 12 month Community Corrections Order

At the committal hearing the Magistrate discharged our client on recklessly cause serious injury and the reckless conduct charge on submissions by our barrister. We also argued that the police had failed to prove that there was a serious injury. Ultimately we sought judicial input and the judge agreed with our position and encouraged parties to resolve on a lesser summary charge.

Exceed Speed over 45kph, Fail to Comply with s60 Notice – All Charges Withdrawn at Contested Hearing

Case: Highway Patrol Officer Misleads Client in Section 60 Rejection Notice.

Our client was served with a Section 60 Road Safety Act Notice requiring him to provide information about a driver who drove his vehicle at over 45kph the speed limit and was captured by a traffic camera. Our client nominated a driver which was rejected by the police officer having spoken to the nominated driver.

Charges/ Ch1 (Exceed speed by 45kph); Ch2 (Fail to comply with s60 Notice); Ch3 (Make misleading statement)

Result/ All charges withdrawn on submissions at Contested Hearing.

We reviewed the police brief and noted that the highway patrol officer did not speak to the nominated driver, instead he spoke with his brother. Despite that, he stated in our client’s rejection letter that he had spoken to the nominated driver “rejected” the nomination. Counsel for our client made submissions that these circumstances were not a valid rejection and ultimately the prosecution agreed to withdraw all charges.

Drug Driving 2nd Time – Adjourned Undertaking, Without Conviction

Case: Driver caught for drug driving 2 times in 1 month

Our was intercepted by a routine police booze bus on the Burwood Highway. She tested negative for any alcohol in her breath, however she tested positive on the roadside drug test.

Charges/ Ch1 (Drive with MDMA in oral fluid); Ch2 (Drive with methylamphetamine in oral fluid); Ch3 (Drive with MDMA in oral fluid, alternative charge)

Result/ 12 month good behaviour bond, 12 months license loss, $500 donation to the Court without conviction 

We negotiated with the Prosecution to roll up the charges to a single offence of drug driving and provided Court support letters and medical documents to the Magistrate, so that our client only received the minimum mandatory license loss.

Drug Trafficking – Withdrawn

Case: Drug trafficker caught after freeway crash

Our client was intercepted by Police after crashing on the Calder Freeway. Police found methylamphetamine on him at the time and later searched his property, where more drugs were found. The total amount of meth was found to weigh 49 grams. Our client also breached his corrections order for drug trafficking, 2 months prior to this incident.

Charges/ Ch1 (Traffick Meth); Ch2 (Possess Meth); Ch3 (Possess ecstasy); Ch4 (Possess Viagra); Ch5 (Drug driving (Meth); Ch6 (Drive whilst suspended); Ch7 (Careless driving); Ch8 (Deal with money suspected of being proceeds of crime.)

Result/ Ch1 (Traffick Meth) withdrawn; Plea Guilty Ch2-8: 12 months license loss, Released from prison after 156 time served with a corrections order variation for the previous offending.

We negotiated with the prosecution to withdraw the drug trafficking charge over several months. Our client was already on a Corrections Order for drug trafficking, so having drug trafficking withdrawn saved our client over 1 year in jail if he plead guilty to that charge.